Florida classroom bookshelves left empty as education reform law goes into effect

"And this from Alabama" S2 #220
a) !
b) There's no shaming the shameless.
Any ideology that's so intrinsically pernicious its advocates need censorship to advance it is automatically alarming.

Generally a superior welcomes competition, confident that such competition will demonstrate, confirm superiority.
Those that advocate / practice suppression confess their own inferiority.

If prevailing is their objective, and they dare not risk legitimate competition to achieve that objective,
they forfeit claim to legitimacy.

And those that knowingly inflict such inferior agenda on children not merely disgrace themselves.
They also handicap children, displacing education with indoctrination.

In the 3rd millennium information culture of smart-phone and Internet, such education suppression
may never have been a more severe, more detrimental impairment.

Censors champion ignorance, and favor fear over enlightenment. Happy 9/11 .
 
On that Alabama law - the article doesn't say whether someone with a child's membership needs a separate parental approval for every "adult" book they want to sign out or can they get a blanket approval for all books whenever they want?

That said, many (most?) libraries have an open floor plan so kids can wander around, find anything they want, and find a seat somewhere and read whatever they want without checking the book out.

And the Brooklyn library makes everything available to US teenagers

 
And in Texas

1789323583304.png

BREAKING
🚨
Dan Patrick is DEMANDING Texas schools pull 2,193 books, including Elie Wiesel's Holocaust memoir Night, and the graphic novel adaptation of Anne Frank's diary.

The 2,193-title list was compiled by Recover America, a conservative activist group, whose legislative liaison Bonnie Wallace stood beside the lieutenant governor at the Texas Capitol on August 19. Night, Wiesel's account of surviving Nazi concentration camps, is objected to because it "contains violence," "controversial religious commentary," and "references to hate."

Anne Frank's Diary: The Graphic Adaptation is on the list. So is All the Light We Cannot See.

So are The Picture of Dorian Gray, Slaughterhouse-Five, Native Son, Hatchet, Flowers for Algernon, and books by Toni Morrison, Maya Angelou, Margaret Atwood, John Green and Rick Riordan.

Patrick said he will pass a law docking a school district an entire letter grade in the state's A-F accountability ratings if one book from that list is found on one shelf anywhere in the district.

Texas uses those ratings to seize control of districts and push out elected school boards. At least six have already been taken over.

"We're coming for the books," Patrick said. "We ask that you do it on your own and remove these books."

The Texas Freedom to Read Project pointed out afterward that SB 13, the 2025 library law Patrick keeps invoking, does not actually require districts to remove any book on that list. Districts still choose their own collections.

Patrick says the books are "so filthy, so dirty, so vulgar, so pornographic" that he refused to open them in front of the women in the room.

SOURCE with comments

If they were serious about removing books with sex and violence the Bible would be at the top of their list.


1789324101011.png
 
1791388286054.png

Texas and Florida account for most of the 12,000 school book bans last year.

PEN America recorded its highest annual total of public school book bans in the 2025–2026 school year, surpassing every year since the organization began tracking them in 2021.

Those bans affected more than 7,300 different titles. The distinction matters: the same book can be counted more than once when multiple districts restrict it.

More than 4,500 titles entered the organization’s index for the first time, another record. New additions included Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë and Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus.

Stephen King was the most banned author, with 312 recorded bans. Young adult author Ellen Hopkins followed with 234.

Texas and Florida accounted for the vast majority of recorded bans. They also have more complete records, partly because local groups have obtained information through public records requests.

PEN America uses “book ban” to cover several kinds of content-based restrictions. These include removing books from libraries or classrooms, making them unavailable during reviews, and limiting access through measures such as parental permission or grade-level restrictions. The total does not mean every book was permanently removed.

The report also raises concerns about schools using artificial intelligence to review their collections. PEN America says these tools can take passages out of context and recommend removing books because other districts have already restricted them.

Books dealing with racism, LGBTQ+ issues and sexuality remain frequent targets, according to the organization.

PEN America says its figures are an undercount because restrictions often go unreported or are difficult to document. Even with those gaps, the latest school year produced the largest total in its five years of tracking.

Learn more:
"Schools banned nearly 12,000 books in 2025-2026, report says." USA Today

=====================================================​

Jayne Eyre was required reading when I was in school - fact is, it was more than just "required reading" - it was one of the books we studied in detail in class.

Have to say that I'd never heard of the other new addition mentioned here. "Lessons in Chemistry" is available on Amazon.

Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus was banned. It’s a book that follows a chemist who experiences sexism in the workplace. After becoming a single mother and a cooking-show host, she teaches science while encouraging women to challenge society’s expectations.

Apparently, this book was banned because women should know their place in society and not question things so the patriarchy can live on.

Jane Eyre, an 1847 novel about an orphan who refuses to sacrifice her independence and self-respect for love, was banned.

It seems like a woman’s independence and self-respect are too much for some Republicans. No wonder they’re pushing wife schools.
 
I do not get why DeSantis would be down on Holocaust education?
Personally I think the Holocaust is vastly oversimplified if it does not also include education about the Balfour Declaration.
But history is reality and everyone should study that so we don't keep repeating mistakes.
 
"Texas and Florida account for most of the 12,000 school book bans last year." #225
One of these States is a downward drooping peninsula.
The other has a big fat panhandle.
Thank god they neither of them have "issues".

"I do not get why DeSantis would be down on Holocaust education?
Personally I think the Holocaust is vastly oversimplified if it does not also include education about the Balfour Declaration.
But history is reality and everyone should study that so we don't keep repeating mistakes." R5 #226
Seems to me you may have answered your own sensible question here R5.
For Trump & DeSantis ilk, education is more a liability than benefit.

"It's a scary idea" SK #227
Scaring someone on Halloween month earns credit.
Does scaring Stephen King earn extra credit?
 
Back
Top