Below The Fold ...

Another case of 20 years later.
I do not at all agree with any prosecution after 5 years or so.
So he should just get off with no repercussions regardless of what he did?

On a related note, in addition to the Statute of Limitations there is something called the Statute of Repose.

And to change gears, in cases where an infant is harmed at birth (so called "bad baby" cases) if the parent's attorney is smart he will only sue on their behalf, not on behalf of the child. That means that when the child reaches the age of majority they can sue in their own right. And that's the reason that medical malpractice insurance (med mal) and hospital professional liability insurance (HPL) are generally written on a "claims made" basis.
 
"Another case of 20 years later.
I do not at all agree with any prosecution after 5 years or so." R5 #661
I'm guessing (with tea-leaf reading level of reliability) the principle of statute of limitations extends far beyond U.S. shores.
Section 3282 of Title 18, United States Code, is the statute of general application. It states that, "(e)xcept as otherwise expressly provided by law," a prosecution for a non-capital offense shall be instituted within five years after the offense was committed.
https://www.justice.gov/archives/jm/criminal-resource-manual-650-length-limitations-period
Sentencing for conviction of crime is considered by some as punishment for the criminal, by others as justice for the victim, and by still others deterrent, to discourage / prevent such crime by others in the future.

The deterrence factor seems to be widely doubted / contested. BUT
if there were no laws against bank robbery, wouldn't it make more sense to carry a gun than a wallet? Want lunch? Rob a bank! There's no law against it. Right?
For that reason, because wallets are ubiquitous, I believe laws against bank robbery help discourage bank robbery, though not entirely. I suspect many bank robbers carry wallets.

"So he should just get off with no repercussions regardless of what he did?" S2 #662

Maybe I'm just too punitive.
Or perhaps the crime R5 imagines as an example isn't as ghastly as my example.

"On a related note, in addition to the Statute of Limitations there is something called the Statute of Repose.

And to change gears, in cases where an infant is harmed at birth (so called "bad baby" cases) if the parent's attorney is smart he will only sue on their behalf, not on behalf of the child. That means that when the child reaches the age of majority they can sue in their own right. And that's the reason that medical malpractice insurance (med mal) and hospital professional liability insurance (HPL) are generally written on a "claims made" basis." S2 #662
a) I've never heard of "Statute of Repose". "Live & Learn"
b) uuuggghhhh !
c) Seems to me #662 is a horrid message well told.

It's so dreadful a message S2, you've reminded me of the following anonymous quotation: If it weren't for lawyers, we wouldn't need them.
"Oh woe is everything!" Grace06
Graceums !
 
So he should just get off with no repercussions regardless of what he did?

On a related note, in addition to the Statute of Limitations there is something called the Statute of Repose.

And to change gears, in cases where an infant is harmed at birth (so called "bad baby" cases) if the parent's attorney is smart he will only sue on their behalf, not on behalf of the child. That means that when the child reaches the age of majority they can sue in their own right. And that's the reason that medical malpractice insurance (med mal) and hospital professional liability insurance (HPL) are generally written on a "claims made" basis.
After 20 years there is absolutely no way to prove anything happened at all.
And in fact, the women should be charged with failing to report the incident right away, since that means she allowed others to not be warned all this time.
Civil suits are another matter since the standard of proof is so much lower.
 
How to say you know nothing about med mal insurance without saying you know nothing about med mal insurance.

After 20 years there is absolutely no way to prove anything happened at all.
There's plenty of proof, all of which was presented when the parents filed their original suit.

And in fact, the women should be charged with failing to report the incident right away, since that means she allowed others to not be warned all this time.

What do you think the original lawsuit (the one by the parents) was?

And the hospital's ethics committee would have been involved reviewing the evidence and taking whatever actions they thought were appropriate at the time.

All of that would be evidence when the child's lawsuit would be filed.

Civil suits are another matter since the standard of proof is so much lower.

All of the lawsuits would be civil cases.
 
Wednesday November 18:
the sun has set in Utqiagvik (Barrow) Alaska, the most Northern U.S. city, inside the Arctic Circle.

Sunset 1:49 local time. Sunrise January 22, 2027.

Gunna get cold there. Not as comfortable as down South in balmy Canada.
 
How to say you know nothing about med mal insurance without saying you know nothing about med mal insurance.


There's plenty of proof, all of which was presented when the parents filed their original suit.



What do you think the original lawsuit (the one by the parents) was?

And the hospital's ethics committee would have been involved reviewing the evidence and taking whatever actions they thought were appropriate at the time.

All of that would be evidence when the child's lawsuit would be filed.



All of the lawsuits would be civil cases.

There is no possible proof I have even heard of.
The civil suit was also 20 years later and without evidence.

{...
A U.S. civil suit filed in 2023 under New York’s Adult Survivors Act, alleging sexual assault during the production of the film Arthur
...}

As for the medial case, I assumed that was just to show how children are exempt from the statute of limitations.
Which has no bearing in the Russel Brandt case that I know of?
 
Back
Top