For my Canadian friends

"It always surprises me how greed the US has always been, like the "54 40 or fight" from 1846." R5 #806
It raises sensible questions.
Perhaps there was -in for a penny, in for a pound-
justification. Meaning, they (we) already plundered from the native nations, & it paid off. Why stop there?

"The US should really not even have gone past the Louisiana Purchase and reached the Pacific at all." R5 #806
The Louisiana Purchase seems like a sleazy deal to me. We "bought" Manhattan Island for a treasure of baubles. BUT !
At least we paid it to approximately those most entitled.

Who got our $money for the Louisiana Purchase? France?

Acquiring Alaska made some sense, though why we'd pay Russia for it, not entirely clear.
None the less, at a reported two pennies per acre, I suppose it was a real estate bargain.
 
It raises sensible questions.
Perhaps there was -in for a penny, in for a pound-
justification. Meaning, they (we) already plundered from the native nations, & it paid off. Why stop there?


The Louisiana Purchase seems like a sleazy deal to me. We "bought" Manhattan Island for a treasure of baubles. BUT !
At least we paid it to approximately those most entitled.

Who got our $money for the Louisiana Purchase? France?

Acquiring Alaska made some sense, though why we'd pay Russia for it, not entirely clear.
None the less, at a reported two pennies per acre, I suppose it was a real estate bargain.

What confuses me is that the Louisiana Purchase stopped at Montana, so how did the US get all the way to the Pacific?
 
"What confuses me is that the Louisiana Purchase stopped at Montana, so how did the US get all the way to the Pacific?" R5 #808
You make a sharp point R5.
Usually we coast until we stop. In that case we didn't stop until we reached the coast, for one Pacific reason.

What little I've read of it indicates Benjamin Franklin imagined the national security implications of U.S. territorially dominating the continent, because
rather than a military aggressor massing a huge invasion force of troop, horse, & cannon on the other side of a land border, the way Russia did on Ukraine,
the United States would be protected by oceans both East & West.

Perhaps that has elevated attacks against US to the air:
- Pearl Harbor
- the attacks of 09/11/01
- China's balloons
- the Soviet missile gap / race

Cyber may or may not be "air". But a land border seems immaterial to it.

Interesting artwork.
Not quite sure what to make of the mirrored asymmetry.
But the pastel shades help generate the mood.
 
What confuses me is that the Louisiana Purchase stopped at Montana, so how did the US get all the way to the Pacific?
Guess students no longer learn about "Manifest Destiny" in school - while it wasn't a major topic we did learn what it was in grade school (Grade 8 IIRC)

====================================================​

Manifest Destiny was a 19th-century doctrine that held the belief that the United States was destined to expand across North America, spreading its culture and democracy. This ideology justified territorial acquisitions and was often linked to the notion of American exceptionalism and racial superiority. Wikipedia

Key Aspects of Manifest Destiny​

Manifest Destiny significantly influenced American history and policy.

  • Cultural Justification — It was rooted in the belief of American cultural and racial superiority, often leading to the marginalization of Native Americans.
  • Territorial Expansion — Key events included the Louisiana Purchase, Texas annexation, and the Mexican-American War, which were driven by this ideology.
  • Political Impact — The doctrine shaped U.S. foreign policy and domestic politics, leading to conflicts over slavery and territorial governance.
  • Opposition — Some politicians and writers opposed Manifest Destiny, arguing it justified imperialism and was morally wrong.
 
"Guess students no longer learn about "Manifest Destiny" in school - while it wasn't a major topic we did learn what it was in grade school (Grade 8 IIRC)" S2 #811
I changed schools like the Pope changes hats, BUT
I believe it was my junior or senior year I encountered the term "manifest destiny", though I didn't bother with the actual coursework.
That was '72 - '73 my junior or senior year.

Worth noting, political sloganeering is an art form honed in the U.S. for centuries. "No Taxation Without Representation" merely an early version.
"The art of political campaigning is to get money from the rich, & votes from the poor, in the promise that you will defend one from the other." actor Billy Connolly
MAGA01.JPG
 
Guess students no longer learn about "Manifest Destiny" in school - while it wasn't a major topic we did learn what it was in grade school (Grade 8 IIRC)

====================================================​

Manifest Destiny was a 19th-century doctrine that held the belief that the United States was destined to expand across North America, spreading its culture and democracy. This ideology justified territorial acquisitions and was often linked to the notion of American exceptionalism and racial superiority. Wikipedia

Key Aspects of Manifest Destiny​

Manifest Destiny significantly influenced American history and policy.

  • Cultural Justification — It was rooted in the belief of American cultural and racial superiority, often leading to the marginalization of Native Americans.
  • Territorial Expansion — Key events included the Louisiana Purchase, Texas annexation, and the Mexican-American War, which were driven by this ideology.
  • Political Impact — The doctrine shaped U.S. foreign policy and domestic politics, leading to conflicts over slavery and territorial governance.
  • Opposition — Some politicians and writers opposed Manifest Destiny, arguing it justified imperialism and was morally wrong.

But Manifest Destiny is insane religious dogma, that I did not think anyone would actually believe.
It is as bad as Zionists claiming to be the Chosen People with a right to their Promised Land.
 
You make a sharp point R5.
Usually we coast until we stop. In that case we didn't stop until we reached the coast, for one Pacific reason.

What little I've read of it indicates Benjamin Franklin imagined the national security implications of U.S. territorially dominating the continent, because
rather than a military aggressor massing a huge invasion force of troop, horse, & cannon on the other side of a land border, the way Russia did on Ukraine,
the United States would be protected by oceans both East & West.

Perhaps that has elevated attacks against US to the air:
- Pearl Harbor
- the attacks of 09/11/01
- China's balloons
- the Soviet missile gap / race

Cyber may or may not be "air". But a land border seems immaterial to it.


Interesting artwork.
Not quite sure what to make of the mirrored asymmetry.
But the pastel shades help generate the mood.

We did not make the Louisiana Purchase until 1803, and I assume Franklin was dead by then?
So it is hard for me to imagine Franklin would have pictured the US ever expanding from coast to coast?

I can appreciate the advantages of size as far as economy of scale, but it also entices the most corruption, and to me the US seems the single most corrupt country in the current world?
It is obvious the 1953 takeover of Iran, 2003 invasion of Iraq, current kidnapping of Maduro, current murder of the Ayatollah, etc., is all just greed for oil.
So I can not help but wish the US was smaller and less corrupt.
 
"I can appreciate the advantages of size as far as economy of scale, but it also entices the most corruption, and to me the US seems the single most corrupt country in the current world?" R5 #814
Corruption is an issue. It's not the only issue. BUT !
There are some in the Middle East that refer to the U.S. as "the great Satan".
There are 193 other nations they could choose for that appellation. They chose US.

"So I can not help but wish the US was smaller and less corrupt." R5 #814
In the 3rd millennium U.S. isolationism is a recipe for self-extinction. BUT !

We can maintain constructive international relations without bombing girls schools, or perpetrating lethal piracy in International open ocean.
 
It's convenient, simple to reduce public opinion of over a century ago to either approval, or disapproval.

I suspect, then as now, public opinion is an amalgam that results in policy influenced by that opinion or not.

In the case of manifest destiny, that was an age where news was scarce, and often word of mouth.
Labor was long and difficult, resulting in life expectancy about half what it is today. They worked themselves to death.

In that context, while individuals may have had a preference about Manifest Destiny one way or another,
many of them may simply not have had the luxury of being able to devote significant time to publicly advocate their position,
as their own survival was the priority.

The serenity prayer surfaced in the 20th Century.
Before that, even if not formalized, it was still practiced by some of our more s a v v y countrymen.

Regardless of whether they were pro or con Manifest Destiny, they understood there wasn't much they could do about it.
That is not an endorsement of it, despite the ancient Latin legal maxim:
qui tacet, consentire videtur:
He who is silent is supposed to consent. The silence of a party implies his consent.
Regarding Manifest Destiny,
possibly so,
possibly not.

the Serenity Prayer
"God grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change,
the courage to change the things I can,
and the wisdom to know the difference."
 
It's convenient, simple to reduce public opinion of over a century ago to either approval, or disapproval.

I suspect, then as now, public opinion is an amalgam that results in policy influenced by that opinion or not.

In the case of manifest destiny, that was an age where news was scarce, and often word of mouth.
Labor was long and difficult, resulting in life expectancy about half what it is today. They worked themselves to death.

In that context, while individuals may have had a preference about Manifest Destiny one way or another,
many of them may simply not have had the luxury of being able to devote significant time to publicly advocate their position,
as their own survival was the priority.

The serenity prayer surfaced in the 20th Century.
Before that, even if not formalized, it was still practiced by some of our more s a v v y countrymen.

Regardless of whether they were pro or con Manifest Destiny, they understood there wasn't much they could do about it.
That is not an endorsement of it, despite the ancient Latin legal maxim:

Regarding Manifest Destiny,
possibly so,
possibly not.

Oddly enough there more than 1 solution.
The larger or stronger the country, the more abusive they can be.
So then the solutions to prevent abuse are:
Have smaller countries.
Have one large country.
Be less abusive.
 
Back
Top